|
Hi,
All in all, if you know, or have studied music history a little, you will find that it is overly structured by people that compiled information after the fact and the moment ... in other words, by the time the music was defined, the composers were already gone.
So, speed to the 20th century and music history now shows Jazz and Rock as two more idioms that are throwing music definitions for a loop. Basically, "music" has no definition today at all ... and probably should stay that way for a while until we learn to determine some proper definitions and work.
I have a simplistic way to look at it ... some say it is idiosyncratic, and some say that it is inspired by this and that ... but in the end it looks like this:
Look at a score for a rock song ... 4 lines!
Look at a score for an orchestra symphony ... 40 lines or so, sometimes more when you have an opera!
When you have ... let's say 40 instruments running ... you do not have the capability to listen to it and discern the totality of the music as well as you do rock and jazz, because of their simplified formats. Ohh, well, we know and have heard Beethoven and Verdi, and Puccini, or Mahler ... but remember those scores had 30 to 40 lines of instruments coming together to say something.
Now, here comes Frank.
I think that he knew that ... and thought that jazz and rock were not exactly hard ... and mostly were just simplistic notions about notes and chords ... which is very true when you compare to the pace in a lot of classical music. So Frank wanted to do something that was different, but he could not do so within the confines of today's standard music ... you can not have a band and survive with it, specially in those days, doing what everyone else was already doing ... so you make a choice!
So I like to say that a lot of Frank's music has more than 4 lines on the score ... just for fun. Others, here, think that he is idiosincratic, because he mixed this pop music bit with something else underneath it in order to make it weird and out of place, and yet ... it sounds fine when you and I hear it!
If you want to learn about "music", you have to let go ... any definition for it. Let what is there ... show you what is there ... and then you have something to work with.
The thing about "Varese" and "Stravinsky" is a bit over rated, if not strange, because if there is one thing you will find is ... that maybe one or two people, ONLY, in this board, have ever heard Varese, and have any idea what his music is about! ... so when someone writes that about music and Frank, it is rather like saying ... Frank is not interested in rock'n'roll ... but that doesn't mean he is not going to make fun of it for a few seconds in the middle of his piece!
|