|
ronnys - i recon a plain murder charge covers this stuff, still....<br><br> what is the qualititive difference, and lets take the most extreem senarios for the sake of the argument, between a white kkk member murdering a black man simply cause the colour of his skin and a black homophobe gangster rapper murdering a homosexual cause he is gay ? please tell me , cause i really do not know.<br><br>also, we are talkin murder in cold blood here , the law recognises manslaughter and diminished responsibility - lets ignore those for this one.<br><br>also, i know these proposed laws would not reduce such murders, as those who committ them do not weigh up the odds. why should a hate law be any more of a deterrent than the death penalty ? - which i am for , for all murders regardless of race ( though ironically not for women killers , thats my soft spot see ).<br><br>intent - what we here call the hate crime , but really the motive , is already a neccessary prerequesit to the vast majority of convictions , so we already have what you want - going from the above.<br><br>in fact wes all talkin fruit again - i just realised. so what we want is to stop people killing others because of their skin colour , sexual pref. of other basic part of ones identity / makeup . well, i dont recon any law will do that as the phenomona is too rare in western world any more than an extra law above the ones we have for murder can stop mr.x killing mr. y over their mutual love for miss. z.<br>i recon you can increase police resources to catch the killers but not eliminate this type of killing - and hey , lets see all these sickos in the chair - im just wary of dumb legislation ( which costs the govt. far less than extra police ). its easy to make a law to appease our conscionces and it may make us feel good - just dont expect it to work - pessemistic , well sorry.<br><br>i dont really know how much of a prob. hate murders are and i would like some stats on typical murder senarios - a % for the followingv - <br><br>1 - man kills wife in kitchen in fit of rage.<br><br>2 - wife gets lover to kill husband for insurance money.<br><br>3 - all armed robberies<br><br>4 - terriorist acts ( inc. 9/11 & oklahoma )<br><br>5 - woman kills child - cant cope.<br><br>6 - child abduction killings.<br><br>7 - racially motivated murder - all breakdowns and combinations please white on black , black on white etc..<br><br>8 - gang related killings inc. inter ethic feuds , mafia feuds , triad feuds , yardi feuds , russian mafia feuds. all internal and external stats please.<br><br>9 - family kills old relatives in secret - too expensive / too much bother<br><br>10 - one off whacko celebrity killings / assassinations.<br><br>id like stats for these , are there any ? cause without em we have no perspective as to how big a prob the hate murder is . <br><br>i have a 5 year old , and child abduction / killing is the big thing in the uk rite now , no ammount of laws will stop it. i wish there was a way , but lets get real here. the other thing is these far out, rare events make great copy for the media they seem bigger probs than they really are they. <br><br>please dont say im glossin over the question ronnys , im not man - i dont like people who do the stuff you describe much - theres just more than one way to skin a cat - der hate laws aint it i believe. <br><br>mungo. <br> <br><br>
_________________ Drink..............it provokes the desire, but it takes away the performance
|