The_Acadian_2 wrote:
Ok lets put out the negativity and get on with it....I suppose that the legacy will be kept alive by us. We are the ones who appreciate his genius the most. ...
(As in a previous post - this is based on my own late father's experience and the fact that my mom in 31 years has published almost twice what he did in his own time!)
You can only study the work that is available.
But you have to have the academic/intelectual ability and perception to realize that ... this is not about "it's my family" ... or "my idea" ... or "your idea" ... in the end, all that matters is ... is the work visible so people can get to it ... and your answer is suggesting that all the work that is visible is the work that is going to get the least critical study of all ... another version of DinahMohum or yeat another jazz'y jingle.
The hard part, and I'm sure Gail is faced with that, is that a lot of the stuff that is out there is so isolated that at times it is impossible to think it up as to how to bring it about. Since none of us can read the future with 100% accuracy, there is no way that anyone can know the answer to this ... but I can say one thing based on our family ... the interest, and the studies got massive after he passed away, and people found ... there was a lot more here, and with my mom's own ability to discuss things and understand them ... I often thought that she had a much clearer perspective on things than he did, btw!!! ... she could be emotional, but a lot of times she cut through a lot of crap to say the right thing! ... these ended up getting more visible and published, most of it of the critical and analytical side of things on my dad's work.
So, my thinking still is ... take the chance. Release the strange stuff and the wierd stuff. So one of these days someone is going to say ... that's some awesome composition ... and play it ... instead of it being a rock band playing in a bar a version of DinahMohum, which is going to get Gail her check from BMI/Ascap (whichever!) around $50 bux each month, maybe $51.
The main issue right now, and this board is one of the better ones so far I have seen in discussing an artists music, is ... what are we (yep ... WE) going to do about it?
I'm not going to show up at Gail's house to talk about this ... I would gladly come over for a cup of tea and a fun yap ... but not to tell her what to do with the legacy of her man's work, which SHE HAS A RIGHT to decide what to do with it ... and probably as time goes by, she might change her views on it.
But give her some credit ... I really doubt that you, or I, would know him a lot better than she did! Please allow her to live that space and handle it as only a mother would know how to do. Sooner or later the child grows up and the mom understands ... she'll get there. It's all a part of growing, and in this case, in a very harsh reality ... she can't let him go, because she's working on the material and whatnot every single hour of every day ... she can't have the peace of mind that she deserves ... and it's not fair for us to sit here and insult her intelligence and feeling for wanting to protect her child ... or in this case husband.
So, yeah ... ciao to the negativity please!