zootallurs wrote:
I agree with you. When I went to see Frank (4 times between 1975 - 1984), there was a special feeling in that you never know what might happen - a surprize guest, the secret word for the evening and audience participation, etc. With ZPZ I only had that feeling the first 2 tours 2006-2007. Dweezil has a talented band and they play Frank's music well, but it DOES lack the spontaneity of a Frank Zappa show. When Frank performed he might, all of sudden break into "Louie Louie" followed by a reggae beat, only to play something in an odd time signature. With Dweezil, its like "this is how it was played on the record, so the band will play it that way", although he is starting to improvise some what. Frank knew how to interact with his audience while DZ seems uncomfortable in that role. Frank was a ringmaster, Dweezil is the band leader. To me that is the difference. I do realize that you really can't compare Dweezil concerts to Frank's, simply because ZPZ is a tribute act, whether you care to admit it or not and Frank was a true original.
When it comes to "In The Moment" basically some people have no clue as to what they are saying and hearing be it if is 1981 or 2010. The long time Zappa fans are more in tune with the show to show changes as a historian from studying Official Catalog & AUD tapes than what they were comprehending in the middle of a show when it was happening. The where is Ike Willis complaints Halloween 81 showed me enough how fans were clueless to those difficult arrangements with Steve Vai in the band and how far Frank had come with a Rock & Roll ensemble. I had to witness Midget Sloatman talk to people asking fans if they actually witnessed what Steve Vai was doing or if they were lost in the Ike Willis' knitted hat ideology. Today I ask myself if some of these same fans are lost in the Ike Willis Crack Pipe Ideology.
1981 Halloween at the Palladium had none of the 1978 & 1973 Audience participation elements but it sure had tons of FZs serious music elements. Never in 1981 did I say where is an Ike Willis "Hi Ho Silver". I am not saying that some of the fans did not recognize secret words, Louie Louie or a little indulgence in Stravinsky's Histoire du soldat at any given show of any given tor but more fans than not at the time were there for the Dinah-Moe Humm and familiarity than some in the community think. Dweezil feels less of a need to have to play Dinah-Moe Humm than FZ ever had to keep a set of fans who paid for a ticket to go home hearing what they wanted to hear. There has not only been variant forms of Audience Participation that even FZ gave up on for many tours buut when DZPZ does Audience Participation I don't compare it to FZ shows that had it or did not. It is something that on occasion was part of what FZ was doing. Factually speaking Dweezil is throwing in "tribute quotes" on a nightly basis to Randy Rhoads and just how many Zappa fans realize that when it is happening. DZ conducts the band, Sorry if there is not enough Louie Louie quotes for anyone's ejectamenta quotients. With more and more tours more and more of every aspect of FZs canon is delved into. Frank did so many things over so many tours. DZPZ has toured for 4 years and no one has ever sounded this good or dug this deep into FZs canon. It continues to evolve sounding far better than many of FZs performances and records. 2010 just keeps bringing so much more of that evolutionary path that has always been done as Authentically as possible.
Plain and simple the 4 year touring adventure is not represented in mass quantities for anyone to do a critical analysis yet.
I have seen them over 20 times and I think I have a better general overview of progress than some but that is just my perspective.
When the CDs & DVD/Blu-Ray projects get released from 2007-2009 then you can add that to your evolutionary analysis.
But then just as 1969 turned to 1970 , 2009 turned to 2010..... and yet but also more variables for deviation. DZPZ just keeps evolving and some fans just do not realize what the hell is happening because they compare a memory of what they happened to see over a small sampling of shows over 4 years to 30 years of FZs musical performance. Dweezil will be taking a Les Paul out this tour. Who knows maybe "Beat It With Your Fist" or countless other arrangements from 1980 & 1981 where FZs played LEs Paul a significant amount of the time will be added to the repertoire. Regardless DZPZ repertoire does contain deviation from the norm. One just needs to use their eyes and ears.